Tuesday, March 1, 2011

What Have I Missed? Review: How I Live Now by Meg Rosoff

This is supposed to be my February book...but I ran out of days in February, thanks to my vacation/honeymoon. So here's the anxiously-awaited (if responses to my Goodreads review tweet are any indication!) of 2005 Printz Award winner How I Live Now.

How I Live NowIn an attempt to escape her father and her horrible new stepmother, Manhattanite Daisy is spending the summer in rural England with family she hardly knows - her mother's sister and her four children. What is supposed to be a boring and relaxing summer takes a turn for the unexpected when, a day after her aunt has left the country on business, war breaks out in England.

Alone in the countryside, the five kids band together as a family in ways Daisy never imagined possible - from becoming so close they're practically telepathic to the decidedly more than familial love she shares with Edmond. But as the danger moves closer to their secluded outpost, Daisy must draw on reserves of strength she hardly knows she has to try to keep the little family together.

Pretty much every review of this I saw before going in brings up the incest - and now I guess I'm guilty of that too. But all of those reviews made such a big deal out of it I was sure I was going to end up with a romance story with some vaguely dystopian feelings. Let me assure you, that's totally not the case. Really, I'm kind of surprised that cousin-incest really gets people up in arms at this point. Just because you don't want to bang your cousin doesn't mean it's actually the grossest thing in the world. Much grosser: undead boyfriends that watch you sleep and try to control who you can spend time with. Or kidnappers. Abusive relationships of any kind, really. Priorities, people.

What this is, is a survival story. This is about how Daisy finds the strength, through extraordinary circumstances, to stop beating herself up and rediscovering her family and her will to live.

But ultimately, that wasn't quite enough to keep me riveted to the story. I put the book down a couple of times and wandered away to read something else. It may have had something to do with the writing style - it's very postmodern what with its complete absence of quotation marks. Considering the kids are pretty much psychic that makes it very hard to tell what is actually spoken and what is thought. The psychic-abilities were a bit random themselves - the whole of the writing just felt rather unsettling and unjustified.

What I did like was how Rosoff was able to subtly show how Daisy evolves over the course of the novel. There are hardly any moments when these changes are stated outright and instead they're left for the reader to pick up on and contemplate. An excellent example of an author trusting her audience to get it without hitting us over the head with character development or Messages.

Comments (3)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Okay, so the things you liked about the book are all exactly the same as what I loved -- it just sounds like, in your case, they weren't enough to trump the obnoxious voice (which I've come to love because I know it's intentional and I feel it works, but which initially made me hate this book) and a few other things. The telepathy was totally a stretch, and I still have a bit of a hard time buying it, but I'm willing to accept it as (1) a byproduct of the almost supernatural powers of her cousins, and (2) the sort of thing a particularly dramatic teenage girl would believe she felt, even if she didn't.

Interesting review!
1 reply · active 734 weeks ago
The telepathy was just so out of nowhere for me that it was irritating. I can totally understand feeling like you have a deep mystical connection with a person you love, but it would pop up just enough as potentially literal telepathy that it was irritating - I've never been much a fan of magical realism, either, and this was like some postmodern magical realism mash up that was just too much for me to really enjoy.
I hadn't read many reviews before I picked up this book, so the cousin relationship was new to me, but didn't bother me either--I was somewhat surprised to see, as you did, that others had made more of it. I agree the telepathy seemed a bit odd, coming all of a sudden and only appearing now and then.

Post a new comment

Comments by

Related Posts with Thumbnails